Tis the season to assault genre conventions
Man, this season is great. Unfortunately it’s great in ways that require a lot of context, because my three favorite shows this season are all appealing to me, at least in part (Nana is just a great story) becuase I’m kind of tired of certain anime genre’s overused conventions.
Mah Big Three are: Nana (The anti-virgin ballad), Ouran High School Host Club (The hard-gay rabu-rabu comedy, without actual gay, or rabu-rabu, though there is comedy), and The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya (The deconstructionist hyper-ironic superflat opus).

It’s not a tumor!
Jyu oh sei, 01
Alright, this makes either 10 or 11 shows I’m watching right now; I’ve sort of of lost count. There are inevitable Lord of the Flies comparisons. It’s airing in the Noitamina time slot, but I don’t actually know if Noitamina is still, like, in existance. I can see some female targetting here, but of the more traditional type; details after the cut.
Black Lagoon, 02
Alright, gotta catch up on some other work, so nothing extensive here, but Black Lagoon is officially super awesome.

That other Haruhi Show
I’m really glad Ouran High School Host Club is getting a Solar fansub. That means all three of my favorite shows of this season (This, Nana, and the Haruhi SuzuMouseClub TV Show) have really good subbers behind them (Solar, Live-eviL, and a.f.k respectively). I’m pretty happy with any sub that isn’t really really bad, since I don’t speak Japanese, but there are times when I can tell an idiom isn’t translating properly (like when Tamaki is talking about water and beautiful men).
Anyway, I probably won’t write any more reactions for this show. It’s good. It’s really really really funny. But I don’t know that I will really ever have much more to say about it. This covers my response after episodes one through three.

Big Gay Ben
Utafurrirumono, 01-02
Apparently Utawarerumono is based on some furry eroge. If I’d known this before I watched it, I might not have watched it. It’s not that I have anything against furry eroge or whatever, it’s just that the three prior experiences I’ve had with anime based on eroge were all very short-lived due to immense boredom. Air I think I sat through 1.5 episodes of before turning it off. Canvas 2 would have been less, except it turned up as a random sampler at CWRU AnSoc. FSN I think I made it through maybe five minutes before stopping it in disgust. Sooooo boring. But this piece of shit is going to be the second instance of a show destroying a useful metric I’ve had for dismissing anime without watching them (Mai Hime destroyed the No-tv-anime-scored-by-Kajiura-Yuki-just-get-the-OST-instead rule).

Eroruu
Kintama, 01-02
Gintama appears to be Excel in the future with samurai, or something. I didn’t exactly follow all of what was happening (translation felt a little dodgey in places), but since this is more meta-humor and slapstick (i.e. Excel, FLCL) than situation comedy, I didn’t particularly care.
I didn’t really think it was that funny over-all, but there were some amusing bits. Breakdown of said bits follows.
The Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi, 03
I don’t have a whole lot to say about this episode. It continues to have amazing animation. I laughed a few times, but didn’t get terribly excited. It almost felt like an addendum to episode two. Fortunately it looks like things will pick up again in the next episode.

Haruharu Haruhi. She just needs a guitar and a Vespa.
The Melancholy of Suzumiya Haruhi, 01: Immersion Tactics
Immersion. It’s not just for saving the damned. Every fucking book lover in the world, and one blind starship engineer harp on about how books will take you to new and fantastic worlds. If a text doesn’t somehow steal my focus from the world around me, then I tend to become rapidly bored with it. Immersion isn’t the only way to engage a reader, but it is an important one. In multi-player (PnP, mmo, or larp) role-playing games, the issue of immersion is often significant, because it is so easy to shatter. I remember one pick-up group I joined playing Dungeons and Dragons online, where the team-leader refused to respond to modern English slang (“What does ‘yo’ mean?”), and tried to insist people precede every sentence with “ye” or “lo!” or “Behold!” or some shit like that. Alright, he was retarded, and he had a very silly concept of appropriate in-character language, but I at least understood his consternation. It’s sort of challenging to pretend you’re Gandalf the Grey if Frodo keeps saying things like “WTF. I PWND THIS RING QUEST n00b! Balr0g’d!”. While creating a truly immersive experience is a challenge, there is some basic requisite consistency necessary to bring the viewer / reader / player into the world of the text at all. This, I think, is why breaking the 4th wall is such dodgy business: it usually wrecks immersion.

Boo! I’m John the Baptist!*